Wondering whether Planet Fitness or Crunch Fitness is the best choice for your fitness journey? Here’s the answer: Planet Fitness is ideal for beginners seeking an affordable, no-judgment gym, while Crunch Fitness is better for those who want more equipment, classes, and serious strength training. Choosing the right gym depends on your goals, budget, and preferred workout style.
Both gyms are popular and affordable—but knowing the differences can save you money, time, and frustration. In this guide, you’ll get up-to-date membership costs, amenities, pros, cons, and expert tips for choosing the best fit. We’ll cover recent price changes, new policies, and real user experiences to help you make an informed decision.
Summary:
- Planet Fitness: Low cost, easygoing vibe, basic equipment, best for beginners.
- Crunch Fitness: More serious fitness options, free weights, group classes, HIIT zones, higher value for active users.
- Update: Both chains updated their pricing and offerings this year (see below for exact fees and links).
Membership Costs & Tiers in 2025
Planet Fitness Membership Options
- Classic Membership: $15/month (increased from $10, early 2025 update).
- Black Card: $24.99/month — adds multi-club access, guest privileges, massage chairs, tanning, and PF+ digital classes.
- Annual Fee: Usually $39–$49 depending on club and region.
- Initiation Fee: Sometimes waived during promotions.
Crunch Fitness Membership Options
- Base: $9.99/month with a 12-month contract. Month-to-month memberships are $14.99–$19.99 depending on location.
- Peak: $24.99/month — includes group classes, multi-club access.
- Peak Results: $29.99/month — unlimited guest privileges, advanced classes, hydro-massage, and online Crunch+ workouts.
- Crunch Signature (Premium): $50–$150/month (for luxury clubs in select cities).
- Annual Fee: Typically $39–$89.
Price Comparison Table
| Gym | Entry Price | Best Value Plan | Annual Fee | Guest Pass | Group Classes | Multi-Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planet Fitness | $15/mo | $24.99 Black Card | $39–$49 | Yes (Black) | No (few) | Yes (Black) |
| Crunch Fitness | $9.99/mo | $29.99 Peak Res. | $39–$89 | Yes (Peak Res.) | Yes | Yes (Peak+) |
Gym Amenities & Equipment
Planet Fitness
- Atmosphere: “Judgment Free Zone”—relaxed, welcoming for all.
- Equipment: Cardio machines, basic resistance machines, limited free weights (usually max 60 lb dumbbells), no power racks.
- Extras: Massage chairs, tanning, 24/7 access at most locations, locker rooms, PF+ app.
- Policies: Strict on gym etiquette—“Lunk Alarm” discourages grunting and dropping weights.
Crunch Fitness
- Atmosphere: Energetic, lively, caters to all levels but especially strength trainers.
- Equipment: Free weights, power racks, Olympic lifting platforms, squat racks, kettlebells, functional training zones, turf areas.
- Extras: Group fitness classes (Zumba, cycling, yoga), HIIT zones, personal trainers, saunas (in some clubs), Crunch+ streaming workouts, towel service (premium).
- Policies: Supportive of strength training; no “Lunk Alarm.”
Pros & Cons
Planet Fitness Pros
- Very affordable, especially for beginners
- Welcoming, non-intimidating environment
- 24/7 access at many clubs
- Massage chairs, free fitness training (basic)
- Many locations (2,700+ worldwide)
Cons:
- No heavy lifting (no squat racks or barbells over 60 lb)
- Few group classes
- Not ideal for advanced strength training
Crunch Fitness Pros
- Wide range of equipment, including free weights & racks
- Lots of group classes & HIIT options
- Suitable for both beginners and experienced athletes
- Premium “Signature” clubs for upscale experience
- Great value at Peak/Peak Results tiers
Cons:
- Some locations pricier, especially Signature
- Crowded at peak times in busy cities
- Annual/maintenance fees may be higher
Real-World Examples & Member Reviews
Planet Fitness:
“Perfect for getting started. I felt comfortable from day one and the price is unbeatable. But when I wanted to lift heavier, I outgrew it.”
– Reddit user review, 2025
Crunch Fitness:
“I switched from Planet Fitness to Crunch because I wanted to deadlift and do HIIT classes. More variety and worth the extra cost!”
– Reddit user review, 2025
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a contract for Planet Fitness or Crunch?
- Planet Fitness: Month-to-month, with a small annual fee. No long-term contracts.
- Crunch: Month-to-month and yearly options. Some deals require a 12-month contract for best rates.
Which gym is best for weight loss?
- Both gyms can help with weight loss, but Crunch offers more group fitness options and high-intensity interval training, which may help burn more calories.
Which gym is better for bodybuilders?
- Crunch Fitness is much better for bodybuilders and powerlifters. Planet Fitness does not have heavy free weights or power racks.
How do I cancel my membership?
- Planet Fitness: Visit your home club in person. Some locations allow cancellation via mail.
- Crunch Fitness: Varies by location; some may require written notice or in-person cancellation.
Conclusion: Planet Fitness or Crunch—Which Should You Choose?
Choose Planet Fitness if you’re new to the gym, want a simple workout, and care about a low price with minimal intimidation.
Choose Crunch Fitness if you want more variety, love group fitness, or need free weights and advanced training zones.
Ready to get started? Visit Planet Fitness or Crunch Fitness for current deals and sign-up offers. Try a free guest pass to test out the vibe before committing.
Take action today—your healthiest, happiest self awaits!